0 items in Cart
My Favorite Muffins  Logo
  • Home
  • Locations
  • Catering
  • Muffin Gifts
  • About
  • Franchising
  • Order Online
  • 0 items in Cart
  • Home
  • Locations
  • Catering
  • Muffin Gifts
  • About
  • Franchising
  • Order Online
Group Order Sign Up For Deals

My Favorite Muffins (Centerville) Online Ordering Menu

175 E ALEX-BELL ROAD
Centerville, OH 45459
(937) 434-2535
7:00 AM - 2:00 PM
95% of 616 customers recommended
Start your carryout or delivery order.
Check Availability

GOURMET SANDWICHES

Served on your choice of fresh baked bagel or bread along with a dill pickle spear.
B.L.T. (390-550 Cal) 
Bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, and mayonnaise.
$7.49+
Classic Turkey (420-580 Cal) 
Roast turkey, lettuce, tomatoes, and mayonnaise.
$7.49+
Mediterranean Veg-Out (370-620 Cal) 
Hummus or cream cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, cucumber, green peppers, and red onions.
$7.49+
Grilled Chicken (450-610 Cal) 
Grilled chicken breast, lettuce, tomatoes, and mayonnaise.
$7.49+
Ham & Cheddar (490-650 Cal) 
Ham, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, and mayonnaise.
$7.49+
Tuna Salad (500-660 Cal) 
Tuna salad, lettuce, and tomatoes.
$7.49+

SPECIALTY SANDWICHES

Served on your choice of fresh baked bagel or bread along with a dill pickle spear.
Turkey Club (500-600 Cal) 
Roast turkey, bacon, American cheese, mayonnaise, lettuce, and tomatoes.
$7.79+
Turkey & Havarti (540-700 Cal) 
Smoked turkey, Havarti cheese, lettuce, and tomatoes, with a shmear of onion and chive cream cheese.
$7.79+
Holey Guacamole (350-510 Cal) 
Roast turkey, guacamole, green peppers, lettuce, and tomatoes.
$7.79+
Chicken Caesar (490-650 Cal) 
Grilled chicken breast, Parmesan cheese, tomatoes, lettuce, and our special Caesar dressing.
$7.79+
Kick-N-Roast Beef (440-600 Cal) 
Roast beef, horseradish sauce, lettuce, and tomatoes.
$7.79+
Big Apple Club (490-650 Cal) 
Ham, roast turkey, bacon, American cheese, mayonnaise, lettuce, and tomatoes.
$7.79+
Roma Italian (550-710 Cal) 
Ham, hard salami, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, and vinaigrette dressing.
$7.79+

TRIPLE-DECKERS

Served on your choice of toasted bread along with a dill pickle spear.
California Club (799-1078 Cal) 
Smoked turkey, Havarti cheese, guacamole, cucumber, lettuce, tomatoes, and mayonnaise.
$8.79+
Classic Club (799-1078 Cal) 
Roast turkey, bacon, cheddar, lettuce, tomatoes, and mayonnaise.
$8.79+

TOASTED SANDWICHES

Served on your choice of fresh baked bagel or twist along with a dill pickle spear.
Spicy Italian (799-1078 Cal) 
Ham, hard salami, provolone, pepperoncini peppers, red onions, lettuce, tomatoes, and vinaigrette dressing.
$8.79+
Cafe Chicken Melt (799-1078 Cal) 
Grilled chicken breast with ham, Swiss, honey mustard, lettuce, and tomatoes.
$8.79+
Deli-Style Turkey (799-1078 Cal) 
Sliced roast turkey breast, Swiss, thousand island dressing, lettuce, and tomatoes.
$8.79+
Roast Beef Grinder (799-1078 Cal) 
Thinly sliced roast beef with marinara sauce, green peppers, and melted provolone.
$8.79+

BREAKFAST SANDWICHES

Served on your choice of fresh baked bagel.
Breakfast B.L.T. (420-560 Cal) 
B.L.T. with your choice of cream cheese.
$5.49
Morning Classic (430-510 Cal) 
Scrambled eggs and American cheese.
$4.29
Southern Tradition (470-750 Cal) 
Sausage, bacon or ham, scrambled eggs, and American cheese.
$5.19+
Northern Omelet (670-750 Cal) 
Sausage, scrambled eggs, and American cheese, with tomatoes and green peppers.
$5.49
Just Veggies! Omelet (390-470 Cal) 
Scrambled eggs, green peppers, tomatoes, and onions.
$4.49
Start Fresh (480-560 Cal) 
Egg whites, provolone cheese, tomatoes, and turkey sausage.
$5.49
Lox & Cream Cheese (560-730 Cal) 
Lox, cream cheese, tomatoes, and red onions.
$9.99

BAGELS & CREAM CHEESE

Dozen Bagels (3600-6760 Cal) 
$12.99
Mega Deal (6360-11060 Cal) 
18 Bagels & (2) 1/2 lbs. of cream cheese.
$27.49
Dozen Deal (4560-7040 Cal) 
12 Bagels & (2) 1/2 lbs. of cream cheese.
$21.19
Mini Deal (2280-3970 Cal) 
6 Bagels & 1/2 lb. of cream cheese.
$11.49
Breakfast Box (9040-14740 Cal) 
12 Bagels, (2) 1/2 lbs. of cream cheese, 8 jumbo muffins in an easy to transport box/serving tray.
$47.99
8 oz. Cream Cheese (480-850 Cal) 
$4.49
Bagel & Cream Cheese (390-680 Cal) 
$3.19+
Bagel (300-380 Cal) 
$1.39
Half Dozen Bagels (1800-3120 Cal) 
$7.99
Twisted Roll (480-520 Cal) 
$1.89
Bagel Box (4080-7090 Cal) 
$21.99

GOURMET MUFFINS

Jumbo Muffin (560-850 Cal) 
$3.19+
Jumbo Muffin 4 Pack (2240-3400 Cal) 
$11.99
Jumbo Muffin 6 Pack (3360-5100 Cal) 
$15.99
Jumbo Muffin 12 Pack (6720-10200 Cal) 
$29.99
Mini Muffin (80-130 Cal) 
$0.99
Mini Muffins (3) (240-390 Cal) 
$2.59
Dozen Mini Muffins (960-1560 Cal) 
An assortment of freshly baked, cake-like mini muffins. If you have a muffin preference, please note it in the comments and we'll do our best to accommodate.
$7.89
3 Dozen Muffin Tin (2880-4680 Cal) 
Enjoy 3 dozen of our delicious Mini Muffins in a decorative keepsake tin. An assortment of freshly baked, cake-like mini muffins. If you have a muffin preference, please note it in the comments and we'll do our best to accommodate.
$31.99

SPECIALTY COFFEE DRINKS

Espresso drinks, made with your choice of milk.
Mocha 
Espresso, steamed milk, and chocolate sauce.
$4.49+
White Chocolate Mocha 
Espresso, steamed milk, and white chocolate sauce.
$4.49+
Turtle Mocha 
Espresso, steamed milk, caramel, and chocolate, topped with whipped cream and a drizzle of caramel.
$4.89+
Latte 
Espresso, steamed milk, and topped with a dollup of steamed foam.
$4.29+
Creme Caramel Latte 
Espresso, vanilla, and caramel sauce, steamed milk, topped with whipped cream and a drizzle of caramel.
$4.89+
Vanilla Creme Latte 
Espresso, French vanilla syrup, Irish creme, and steamed milk.
$4.89+
Cinnamon Toast Latte 
Espresso, vanilla and cinnamon syrup, and steamed milk.
$4.89+
Cappuccino 
Espresso, steamed milk, and topped with a dollop of steamed foam.
$4.29+
Espresso 
$1.89+

FRUIT SMOOTHIES

A premium real fruit frozen smoothie.
Carribean Colada 
Creamy blend of fresh coconut and juicy pineapple with the right balance of sweetness.
$4.49
Mango Mania 
Sweet, velvety mango.
$4.49
Strawberry Banana  
Fresh-picked strawberry and ripe banana flavors make a natural pair in this delicious fruit smoothie.
$4.49
Strawberry Bomb  
Sweet explosion of fresh-picked strawberry.
$4.29
Wild Berry Blast 
Taste ripe blueberries, sweet blackberries and tart raspberries in every sip.
$4.49

SPECIALTY DRINKS

Non-espresso.
Hot Cocoa 
Made with your choice of milk.
$3.29+
Cafe Caramella 
Caramel syrup, brewed coffee, half & half, topped with whipped cream.
$3.69+
Chai Latte 
Made with Your choice of milk.
$4.29+

ICESPRESSO

Sweet and creamy blended iced coffees.
Latte (300 Cal) 
Sweet and creamy frozen latte.
$4.49
Mocha (370 Cal) 
A rich and creamy frozen mocha.
$4.49
Java Chip (320 Cal) 
Blended chocolate chip mocha.
$4.49
Caramel Decadence (370 Cal) 
Smooth and creamy caramel latte topped with caramel sauce.
$4.49

BREWSTER'S COFFEE

Brewed Coffee (5 Cal) 
$1.99+
Coffee To Go Box (32 Cal) 
$18.99
9 Oz. Retail Package (70 Cal) 
$7.99

BEVERAGES

Soft Drink (0-440 Cal) 
$2.59+
Iced Tea 
$2.39+
Hot Tea 
$1.49

PIZZAAH!

Oven fresh hand crafted pizza bread.
Cheese (600-640 Cal) 
$6.49
Bruschetta (820-860 Cal) 
Fresh tomatoes, mozzarella & oregano.
$6.49
Pepperoni or Sausage (870-1020 Cal) 
Pepperoni or sausage, mozzarella & marinara.
$7.49
Chicken Bruschetta (930-970 Cal) 
Grilled chicken, fresh tomatoes, mozzarella & oregano.
$7.99

SALADS

Freshly made to order. If you wish to eliminate an item from a salad, please note it in the instructions box.
Calypso Chicken (620 Cal) 
Grilled chicken breast, greens, mandarin oranges, walnuts, onion and tomato, dressed with our sweet balsamic vinaigrette.
$7.49
Chicken Club (760 Cal) 
Crisp greens, grilled chicken breast, crumbled bacon, onions, tomato, cucumber & provolone cheese tossed with our creamy ranch dressing.
$7.49
Mediterranean Bread (740 Cal) 
Our own bread, tomato, onion, cucumber, salami, provolone cheese, sun dried tomatoes, green olives and crisp greens. All tossed in our Greek vinaigrette dressing.
$7.49
Grilled Chicken Caesar (560 Cal) 
Crisp romaine with grilled chicken breast, croutons & shredded parmesan cheese, tossed in our caesar dressing.
$7.49
Garden Mix (110 Cal) 
Mixed greens, onions, tomato, green peppers, and cucumber with reduced fat Italian dressing.
$5.89
Classic Caesar (450 Cal) 
Crisp Romaine, croutons, and Parmesan cheese, tossed in our Caesar dressing.
$5.89
Cafe Salad (60-230 Cal) 
Garden mix or classic caesar.
$3.79

CATERING

Specialty Sandwich Boxed Lunch (720-1410 Cal) 
$35.96+
Gourmet Sandwich Boxed Lunch (720-1410 Cal) 
$35.96+
Muffin Dessert Tray (2880-4680 Cal) 
Satisfy any sweet tooth with a platter of 3-dozen assorted bit-sized mini muffins. Great for snacking, breakfast, dessert, or any occasion.
$26.99
My Favorite Platter (7680-11760 Cal) 
Serves 15-20. A perfectly delicious assortment of our famous bite-sized mini & jumbo muffins. Great for snacking, breakfast, dessert, or any occasion!
$34.99
Bites & Minis Platter (4920-7060 Cal) 
Serves 15-20. An assortment of our fresh bagel bites & mini muffins, presented on a catering tray with (2), 1/2 lb. containers of cream cheese.
$39.99
Bit O' Bagel Platter (5940-8250 Cal) 
Serves 12-18. Guests will love sampling bite-sized bits of bagels & 3 selections of specially-blended cream cheese. Your choice of sweet or savory and we do the rest!
$36.99
Your cart is empty.
Accepts Google Pay
Accepts Venmo


  • Visit our Facebook Visit our Yelp
Powered by Menufy © 2023
  • Accessibility
  • Terms
  • Help
  • Privacy
Loading, please wait.